A few days ago my son showed me how to add a link to a post. I said wow that was easy. So it's copy and paste, who'd of thunk.
I googled Motobrick 3700 and Motobrick 1800, came up with a lot of matches.
Posting a photo only takes me a few seconds, but the first photo I posted on Motobrick took me three hours. Strangely, that photo popped up on my previous post and all my posts on that thread, and even posts by other posters. Dunno how I done it, wouldn't be able to do it again if I tried.
https://www.motobrick.com/index.php?topic=11301.msg98578#msg98578Soggz showed me a quicker way to post a photo, thanks Soggz.
Anyways, a small number of cases, yes, but I think there's a pattern that a rattle from the output shaft that suddenly disappears around 2000 points to the auxiliary shaft, around 4000 points to the output shaft. There's more examples, but don't want to thread jack too much. It's odd that a rattle from the output shaft disappears with the alternator removed, but if it does turn out to be a pattern, we can call it a symptom without knowing the reason. Maybe something to do with less drive or turning direction, dunno.
Anyways, I don't think we have to think about it too much, cause there's a BMW service bulletin about the problem. It says the minimum action to be taken is to install a new shim, and check the other items for wear. I guess the bearing would deserve the closest look. Since it takes so long to get to the output shaft, it would make sense to replace both bearings, and other wear items even if they look good. Let's say it's done 100, 000 km, you could say I'm not even going to measure them, I'll just replace with new.